MarketSaturation:TheRisingCostoftheNextClick
Diminishing returns mean that "more spend" often just buys "worse customers" at a higher price. The first pound captures your best prospects. Every pound after that costs more and converts less.
The Finite Audience Problem
You have captured the high-intent hand-raisers. To scale further, you must target colder audiences who need more persuasion.
The people actively searching for your product right now are finite. Once you have captured them, additional spend reaches people who are less ready to buy. Same ad, worse audience, higher cost per conversion.
Audience Quality Degrades
First £10k reaches people searching exact match terms with purchase intent. Next £10k reaches broader matches and audiences. The £50k after that targets Display, YouTube, and upper-funnel where intent is lowest.
Average CPA vs Marginal CPA
Your dashboard shows average CPA. Your bank balance feels marginal CPA.
Average CPA (What Dashboard Shows)
Total cost divided by total conversions. Blends all your efficient and inefficient spend together.
Marginal CPA (Real Cost of Growth)
The cost of acquiring your next customer. Always higher than average. The true cost of scaling.
"The rising tail of CPA is invisible in dashboards but felt in profit margins. Average looks flat while marginal climbs."
The Cannibalisation Risk
Extra spend often targets users who would have bought anyway. Branded search and retargeting are the worst offenders.
- • Branded search: Paying for people typing your name into Google
- • Heavy retargeting: Showing ads to yesterday's site visitors who are already on the path
- • Performance Max brand leakage: PMax claiming credit for brand conversions
These channels look efficient because the audience was converting anyway. You are buying low-quality revenue that cannibalises organic and direct.
Diminishing Returns Curve
Every account has a diminishing returns curve. As spend increases:
- • CPA rises exponentially
- • Conversion rate degrades
- • Marginal ROAS can go negative
- • Quality of customers declines
At some point, every additional pound spent returns less than a pound in profit. Finding that point is the job.
Measuring Incrementality
Stop chasing blended ROAS. You must measure the cost of the marginal conversion.
- Geo-lift tests: Hold out regions and compare sales
- Audience holdouts: Exclude segments and measure impact
- Incrementality analysis: What would have happened without the ads?
- Marginal ROAS tracking: Measure the return on your last pound spent
Strategic Scaling
When marginal CPA rises faster than acceptable:
- • Split Demand Capture from Prospecting: Separate campaigns with different targets
- • Add holdout tests: Prove true lift before scaling further
- • Refresh creative: New creative can unlock new segments
- • Expand catalogue: More products means more demand to capture
- • Accept the ceiling: Not every account can spend infinitely at profit
Stay informed
Get our latest insights on Google Ads strategy delivered to your inbox. No fluff, no spam, just honest thinking.
Unsubscribe anytime. No spam, ever.